Is the HP Reverb G2 Better Than the Index? A Comparison of Two Top VR Headsets

Virtual reality (VR) has become increasingly popular among gaming enthusiasts and tech enthusiasts alike, pushing manufacturers to develop cutting-edge VR headsets. Two of the most renowned options in the market right now are the HP Reverb G2 and the Valve Index. With both claiming top-tier performance, it becomes crucial to compare these two headsets side by side and determine which one comes out on top in terms of features, specifications, and overall user experience.

Display And Image Quality: Analyzing The Resolution, Pixel Density, And Refresh Rates Of The HP Reverb G2 And The Index

The display and image quality are crucial factors to consider when choosing a VR headset. In this section, we will compare the resolution, pixel density, and refresh rates of the HP Reverb G2 and the Index.

The HP Reverb G2 boasts an impressive resolution of 2160 x 2160 pixels per eye, resulting in sharp and detailed visuals. With a pixel density of 703 pixels per inch (PPI), the images appear remarkably crisp and lifelike. Furthermore, the Reverb G2 offers a high refresh rate of 90Hz, ensuring smooth and fluid motion.

On the other hand, the Index also delivers outstanding display quality. It features a slightly higher resolution of 1440 x 1600 pixels per eye, providing excellent clarity. With a pixel density of 615 PPI, the images are incredibly clear and vibrant. The Index offers a variable refresh rate, ranging from 80Hz to 144Hz, allowing users to customize their experience based on their preferences.

When it comes to display and image quality, both headsets offer exceptional visuals. However, the higher resolution and pixel density of the HP Reverb G2 give it a slight edge in terms of clarity and detail. Additionally, the Reverb G2’s 90Hz refresh rate ensures smooth gameplay and reduces motion sickness.

Comfort And Ergonomics: Assessing The Fit, Weight, And Overall Comfort Of Wearing The HP Reverb G2 Versus The Index.

When it comes to comfort and ergonomics, the HP Reverb G2 and the Index offer distinct experiences. The HP Reverb G2 is known for its exceptional comfort, thanks to its redesigned head strap and improved weight distribution. The headset feels snug and secure on the head, even during prolonged usage. Additionally, the Reverb G2’s Halo headband design contributes to better weight distribution, reducing strain on the neck and alleviating fatigue.

On the other hand, the Index also offers a comfortable fit, but some users may find it slightly less ergonomic compared to the Reverb G2. The weight distribution of the Index may vary depending on the individual’s head shape, leading to some complaints of pressure points or the headset feeling front-heavy for some users.

Both headsets are adjustable, allowing users to customize the fit according to their preferences. However, the HP Reverb G2 excels in this aspect, providing a more comfortable and secure fit overall.

Ultimately, the HP Reverb G2’s superior comfort and ergonomics give it an edge over the Index, making it a more favorable choice for users seeking extended VR sessions without discomfort or strain.

Tracking And Controllers: Comparing The Tracking Technology And Accuracy, As Well As The Functionality And Usability Of The Controllers In Both Headsets.

When it comes to virtual reality, accurate tracking and responsive controllers are crucial for an immersive experience. The HP Reverb G2 and the Index both offer advanced tracking technology, but they approach it in different ways.

The HP Reverb G2 utilizes inside-out tracking, which means that the headset’s sensors track the user’s movements without the need for external sensors or base stations. This allows for a more convenient setup and increased portability. However, some users have reported occasional tracking issues, particularly when the controllers are out of the headset’s field of view.

In contrast, the Index relies on external base stations for its tracking system known as lighthouse tracking. This technology provides highly accurate and reliable tracking, even in large play spaces. However, it requires more setup time and limits portability.

In terms of controllers, the HP Reverb G2 uses redesigned controllers that are similar to the Oculus Touch controllers. They are comfortable to hold and offer precise tracking, but the button layout and ergonomics may not be as intuitive for some users compared to the Index controllers.

The Index controllers, also known as Valve Knuckles, are widely praised for their ergonomic design and intuitive hand presence. They feature individual finger tracking, which adds a new level of immersion to VR experiences. However, they can feel slightly bulkier and may take some time to get accustomed to.

Overall, both headsets provide solid tracking capabilities, but the Reverb G2’s inside-out tracking offers convenience while the Index’s lighthouse tracking provides unparalleled accuracy. The choice ultimately depends on the user’s preferences and priorities in terms of setup, portability, and tracking accuracy.

Audio Experience:

The audio experience is a crucial aspect of virtual reality immersion. When comparing the HP Reverb G2 and the Index, it is essential to assess the audio quality and the options available for achieving optimal sound immersion.

The HP Reverb G2 boasts built-in headphones developed with the expertise of Valve’s Index. These over-ear headphones deliver exceptional audio quality, offering immersive soundscapes that enhance the VR experience. The spatial audio technology employed by the G2 ensures accurate positioning of sounds, allowing for an even more realistic and engaging environment.

On the other hand, the Index takes a different approach by providing speakers that are integrated into the headset. These speakers utilize near-field surround sound, resulting in a three-dimensional audio experience that envelops the user. While this setup produces impressive audio, it might not provide the same level of privacy or intensity as headphones.

Both headsets also offer the option to use external headphones for those seeking higher audio fidelity or prefer to use their own preferred audio peripherals.

In conclusion, the HP Reverb G2’s built-in headphones deliver outstanding audio quality, while the Index offers a unique speaker setup that can provide a spatial audio experience. Ultimately, the choice between the two will depend on personal preferences for privacy, audio immersion, and any desire to use external headphones.

Software Compatibility And Ecosystem

The software compatibility and ecosystem of a VR headset play a crucial role in its overall functionality and user experience. When comparing the HP Reverb G2 and the Index in terms of software compatibility, it becomes apparent that both headsets have their strengths and limitations.

The HP Reverb G2 boasts compatibility with Windows Mixed Reality, which allows users to access a wide range of VR content available on the Microsoft Store. Additionally, it is compatible with SteamVR, providing access to an extensive library of VR games and experiences. However, its compatibility with other platforms such as Oculus Rift and PlayStation VR is limited.

On the other hand, the Valve Index offers compatibility with both SteamVR and the Oculus Rift platform, expanding the user’s access to a vast library of VR content from various sources. This compatibility gives the Index an edge over the Reverb G2 in terms of software availability and ecosystem flexibility.

Considering the availability of compatible software and games, the Valve Index enjoys a more established and diverse library compared to the HP Reverb G2. The Index has a strong backing from Valve, known for its immersive gaming experiences, while the Reverb G2 still has some catching up to do in terms of software selection.

In conclusion, while the HP Reverb G2 offers compatibility with notable platforms like Windows Mixed Reality and SteamVR, the Valve Index surpasses it with its broader compatibility including both SteamVR and Oculus Rift. Additionally, the Index benefits from a larger and more diverse software library, making it a more enticing choice for those seeking a wide range of VR experiences.

Price And Value For Money: Analyzing The Price Point And Features Offered By The HP Reverb G2 And The Index To Determine Which Headset Provides Better Value For The Price.

When it comes to purchasing a VR headset, price is often a major consideration. Both the HP Reverb G2 and the Index come at a premium cost, but it’s important to assess the value they provide for the price.

The HP Reverb G2 is more budget-friendly than the Index, making it an attractive option for those looking to enter the world of VR without breaking the bank. Despite its lower price, the Reverb G2 certainly doesn’t skimp on features. It boasts an impressive resolution, pixel density, and refresh rate, comparable to the Index.

On the other hand, the Index offers a higher price tag but provides additional features and capabilities. With its industry-leading tracking technology and highly functional controllers, the Index delivers a more immersive and accurate VR experience. The audio quality of the built-in speakers is also exceptional, further enhancing the overall experience.

Ultimately, the choice between the HP Reverb G2 and the Index will depend on individual budgetary constraints and desired features. Those seeking a more affordable option without compromising on performance may find the Reverb G2 to be the better choice. However, if budget is less of a concern and top-notch features are a priority, the Index offers excellent value for the price.

User Reviews And Feedback

User reviews and feedback play a crucial role in understanding the overall satisfaction and performance of VR headsets. In this section, we will delve into the experiences and opinions of users who have tried both the HP Reverb G2 and the Index.

One common sentiment among users is the superior visual experience offered by the Reverb G2. The high resolution and pixel density of the display have received rave reviews, with users appreciating the level of detail and clarity it provides. Additionally, the Reverb G2’s compatibility with Windows Mixed Reality platform has been praised, as it allows users to access a wide range of compatible software and games.

However, when it comes to tracking and controllers, many users believe that the Index surpasses the Reverb G2. The Index’s lighthouse tracking system has been lauded for its accuracy and reliability, offering a more immersive and responsive experience. Users have also commended the ergonomic design of the Index controllers, which provide better grip and comfort during gameplay.

Overall, user feedback indicates that both headsets have their strengths and weaknesses. While the Reverb G2 excels in display quality and software compatibility, the Index shines in tracking precision and controller functionality. Therefore, personal preferences and specific use cases may heavily influence which headset users prefer.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. Is the HP Reverb G2 better than the Index in terms of display resolution?

The HP Reverb G2 boasts an impressive 2160 x 2160 per eye resolution, offering incredibly detailed and immersive visuals. In comparison, the Index offers a resolution of 1440 x 1600 per eye. Therefore, it can be said that the Reverb G2 provides a higher display resolution than the Index.

2. How do the field of view (FOV) capabilities of the HP Reverb G2 and the Index compare?

While both headsets offer a similar field of view, the HP Reverb G2 provides a slightly wider FOV at 114 degrees compared to the Index’s 110 degrees. Although the difference might not be significant, users may appreciate the enhanced immersion that comes with a slightly larger field of view in the Reverb G2.

3. Which headset offers better tracking: the HP Reverb G2 or the Index?

Both headsets utilize inside-out tracking technology, but the Index has an edge in terms of tracking accuracy and range. With its superior sensors and controllers, the Index delivers a more precise and reliable tracking experience. However, the tracking performance of the Reverb G2 is commendable and should be sufficient for most users’ VR needs.

4. Does the HP Reverb G2 or the Index offer better comfort and ergonomics?

Comfort and ergonomics are subjective factors, but generally, the Index is considered to be more comfortable and user-friendly. Its adjustable strap system and ergonomic design allow for a more customizable and enjoyable fit. The Reverb G2, while comfortable for most users, may require some adjustments to achieve an optimal fit. Ultimately, personal preferences will play a crucial role in determining which headset offers better comfort for individuals.


In conclusion, while both the HP Reverb G2 and the Index are top-tier VR headsets, each has its own strengths and weaknesses. The Reverb G2 excels in visual quality, providing a sharp and immersive experience with its high-resolution display. On the other hand, the Index offers superior tracking and controllers, delivering a more precise and natural interaction within virtual environments. Ultimately, the choice between the two depends on individual preferences and priorities, whether it be prioritizing visual fidelity or seamless tracking.

Leave a Comment